Sorry Everyone - I just noticed in the last "Re: Re: [CAGLE] Mary E. Cagle, b. Aug 1882 TN" message that I had mislabeled the census as 1900 and it should have read 1910. My original question was "Does anyone know why this is not the daughter of William Cagle & Mary Melinda Brewer?" Here is the data from 1900-1930: 1900 Knoxville Ward 10, Knox Co., TN, ED 95, 24th Civil District, 2104 Lily Ave.; 08 June; page 230, family 177; Samuel P. Angel Jr., Enumerator: CAGLE, William, head, w/m, Dec 1842, 57, married 28 years, TN/TN/TN, Day Laborer, Rent CAGLE, Mary M., wife, w/f, Mar 1861, 39, married 28 years, 15/13 children, TN/TN/TN CAGLE, Isaac W., son, w/m, Dec 1880, 19, single, TN/TN/TN, Carder (Woolen Mills) CAGLE, Mary E., daughter, w/f, Aug 1882, 17, single, TN/TN/TN, H???der (Woolen Mills) CAGLE, Biddy O., daughter, w/f, Jan 1885, 15, single, TN/TN/TN, Spinner (Woolen Mills) CAGLE, Francis I., daughter, w/f, Apr 1887, 13, single, TN/TN/TN, Spinner (Woolen Mills) CAGLE, Susan C., daughter, w/f, Jan 1889, 11, single, TN/TN/TN CAGLE, James A., son, w/m, Sept. 1890, 9, single, TN/TN/TN CAGLE, Jasper L., son, w/m, Feb 1893, 7, single, TN/TN/TN CAGLE, Larence J., son, w/m, May 1895, 5, single, TN/TN/TN CAGLE, Eley, daughter, w/f, Mar 1898, 2, single, TN/TN/TN BREWER, John, Father-in-law, w/m, Aug 1832, 67, married 50 years, TN/NC/TN, Farm Laborer BREWER, Elizabeth, Mother-in-law, w/f, Jan 1829, 71, married 50 years, 8/7 children, TN/NC/NC 1910 Knoxville, Knox Co., TN; ED 97, Ward 10; 1325 Dehart Ave.; 18 April; page 95, family 119; Ernest West, Enumerator: HEADRICK, James H., head, m/w, 33, married 9 years, Unknown birthplace of self & parents, laborer, River, rent HEADRICK, Mary, wife, f/w, 27, married 9 years, Mother of 4, 3 living, TN/Unknown/Unknown HEADRICK, Stella, daughter, f/w, 6, single, TN/Unknown/TN HEADRICK, Ola, daughter, f/w, 4, single, TN/Unk/TN HEADRICK, James O., son, m/w, 1, single, TN/Unk/TN World War I Draft Registration Card: James Henry Headerick Permanent Home Address - 1634 Detroit, Knoxville, Knox, Tenn Age in Years - 41 Date of Birth - Sept 2nd 1877 White Native Born Present Occupation - Common Labor Employeer's Name - H. C. Milner Place of Employment or Business - Sand Dredge on Tennessee River Nearest Relative - Mrs. Mary Elizabeth Headerick 1634 Detroit, Knoxville, Knox, Tenn Signed by mark - James Henry Headerick Witness to sig - Mrs. W. Hudson Tall Medium Build Light Blue Eyes Brownish Gray Hair John W. Hudson, Registrar 12 Sept 1918 (Note same street address on WW I Draft Reg Card & 1920 census - and wife's name of Mrs. MARY ELIZABETH Headerick) 1920 Knoxville, Knox Co., TN; ED 93, 12th C.D., Ward 10; 1634 Detroit Ave., 03 Jan; page 5, family 103; James Avery Rush, Enumerator: HEADRICK, James, head, own - mortgaged, m/w, 42, married, TN/TN/TN, laborer, general HEADRICK, Mary, wife, f/w, 37, married, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Stella, daughter, f/w, 15, M written over S, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Olof, son, m/w, 13, single, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Claude, son, m/w, 7, single, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Mary, daughter, f/w, 3, single, TN/TN/TN 1930 Knoxville, Knox Co., TN; ED 47-23, Ward 10; 1634 Detroit Ave.; 08 April; page 65 B, family 208; G. M. Clairborne, Enumerator: HEADRICK, James H., head, own, $2000, m/w, 53, married, married 1st at 23, TN/TN/TN, laborer, Railroad HEADRICK, Mary, wife, f/w, 47, married, married 1st at 18, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Raymond, son, m/w, 24, married, married 1st at 20, TN/TN/TN, laborer, Railroad HEADRICK, Louise, daughter-in-law, f/w, married, married 1st at 17, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Raymond, Jr., grandson, m/w, 1-?4/12, TN/TN/TN HEADRICK, Claude E., son, m/w, 17, single, TN/TN/TN, laborer, University HEADRICK, Mary, daughter, f/w, 13, single, TN/TN/TN Note that the birth date of Aug 1882 for Mary E. Cagle is consistent with the ages of 27, 37 & 47 on each consecutive census year. Mary Lou (Cagle) Cooley