Genie, You are exactly right. Here are my notes for Pinkney Louis Cagle, 1866-1845, Jonathan's Creek, Haywood, NC. 1870 US Fed Census Jonathans Creek, Haywood, NC, 23 Jul, page 9, household 65, Family 65, lines 22 - 31, W G Blaiwell, Asst Marshall CAGLE, William, 45, MW, Farmer, $500/$375, NC Sena, 43, FW, Keeping House, NC Robert, 18, MW, Farm Labor, NC Mary, 17, FW, At home, NC Rebecca, 14, FW, At home, NC William, 12, MW, Farm Labor, NC John, 8, MW, Farm Labor, NC George, 6, MW, NC Louis, 5, MW, NC (this is Pinkney in the 1880 census) Sarah, 1, FW, NC 1880 Haywood Co., NC, Jonathan's Creek PO, ED 96, pg 16, 14 Jun, Household 137, Family 144, lines 37 - 44 CAGLE, William, Self, M, Male, white, 52, NC Farmer NC NC Cenith M Wife M Female W 52 NC Keeps House NC NC John M Son S Male W 30 NC Works On Farm NC NC Sarah A Dau S Female W 11 NC At Home NC NC Pinkney Son S Male W 15 NC Works On Farm NC NC Margret L Dau S Female W 9 NC NC NC Mary G Dau S Female W 7 NC NC NC Zebulon N Son S Male W 4 NC NC NC 1910 US Fed Census Nantahala, Swain, NC, 28 Apr, ED 150, Sheet 10B, Enumerated by Luther H Baker in household 172, family 172, lines 60 - 68 CAGLE, P L, head, MW, 54, M-12, NCV NC NC, Farmer, Literate Nora, wife, FW, 28, M1-12, 2/2, NC NC NC, none, LiterateI Lucias, son, MW, 19, Single, NC NC NC, Farm Laborer, Literate Laura, dau, FW, 17, Single, NC NC NC, none, Literate Ida, dau, FW, 15, Single, NC NC NC, none, Literate Ella, dau, FW, 13, Single, NC NC NC, none, Literate Althie, dau, FW, 11, Single, NC NC NC, none. Literate Georgia, dau, FW, 7, Single, NC NC NC, none MOODY, Marsey?, Niece, FW, 19, Single, NC NC NC, Literate 1920 US Fed Census Highland, Greenville, SC, 5 Jan, ED 37, Sheet 5B, Enumerated by Edmond Stokes in household 31, family 34, lines 91 - 95 CAGLE, Pinkney L, head-rent, MW, 60, M, Illiterate, SC SC SC, Farmer Mary, wife, FW, 25, M, Literate, SC SC SC, none Ollie L, son, MW, 4-3/12, Single, SC SC SC, none Earl L, son, MW, 3 Single, SC SC SC, none A Z, son, MW, 1, Single, SC SC SC, none 1930 US Fed Census Dist 1050, Union, GA, 15 Apr, Lower Young Cane, ED 146-10, Sheet 1B, Enumerated by Bell Casteel in household 17, family 18, lines 88 - 96 CAGLE, Pinkney L, head, MW, 68, M-20, Illiterate, NC NC NC, Farmer Mergie, wife, FW, 37, M-19, Literate, NC NC NC, none Ollie L, son, MW, 12, Single, In Sch, Literate, GA NC NC, Farm Laborer Earl, son, MW, 11, Single, In Sch, Literate, SC NC NC, Farm Laborer A Z, son, MW, 9, Single, In School, Literate, SC NC NC, none J P, son, MW, 8, Single, In School, Literate, GA NC NC, none Leva, dau, FW, 6, Single, In School, GA NC NC Homer, son, MW, 3-7/12, GA NC NC Kromer, son, MW, 1-11/12, GA NC NC Lee Cagle Okla City -- Eugeniarowe@aol.com wrote: I believe the problem simply stated is "Is Pinkney L. Cagle, b ca 1860 - 62, who was married to Mary Moody and who were the parents of A. Z. Cagle, b. Aug. 7, 1921, d. Jan 28, 1970, -- Is this the same person as Pinkney Lewis Cagle who was also married and had a family with Sally Tucker, and is he the son of William Cagle of Jonathan Creek, Haywood County, N. C.? The Mary Moody info is from A. Z. Cagle death certificate in Haywood County. The Sally Tucker info is from "Family Search" which I usually take with a grain of salt until proven otherwise. My grandson in law has his grandfather A. Z.' s Bible but it has no info about his parents or sibblings. Any info will be welcome to get me started on the correct lines for him. Thanks for any help you can give me to help him become better acquainted with his forebearers. And while we are at it do you know anything about Sally Tucker and Mary Moody? Genie See what's free at AOL.com. _____________________________________________________________ Click to become an artist and quit your boring job http://track.juno.com/s/lc?u=http://tagline.untd.us/fc/Ioyw6iifPHmubcIj9dfaJRYoeSAj99y0iF7xmwn7JPle7FkKmW3Aw4/