New information I have Charles Cagle who was married to Malinda Belle Austin the son of Valintine and Martha Austin Cagle, This is out of the Georgia book : John G. Cagle, says the family bible of Valentine Cagle, 1787-1850s, has now come to light, and shows that Charles was not amoung his children . George W. Cagle, c1789-1860s, was a xousin of Valentine, and he is the likely father of Charles Cagle, born 14 Sept. 1817 and died Sept. 26, 1870. and his wife Malinda Belle Austin Cgle, born Aug. 9, 1821 and died on Jan 29, 1877 , they are both buried at Deer Head Cove Cemetery, DeKalb Co. ALA. along with two of there children Mary Jane (Cagle) Case 1842-1912, 2nd child of Charles & Malinda and wife of John W. Case 1839-1884. Margaret Eliz. (Cagle) Blevins 1843-1901 3rd daughter of Charles and Malinda and wife of James Blevins, 1848-1925. Also Malinda's father and mother are buried there Hezekiah Daniel and Nancy Jane Blevins Austin . Brother of Charles , William Cagle, born March 31, 1819, died April 09, 1862 , Big head stones. Williams wife Elizabeth P. remarried to a Mr. McDaniel and she erected his headstone. They are buried in section 16. 1870 Census , Alabama ; Household #13, Dekalb Co. Twp 4/Range 10 Sulphur springs P.O. Cagle, Charles 52 GA Farmer/$1800/$1158 Malinda 48 AL Keeping House Margaret E. 27 " Keeping House Nancy C. 25 " " " Wm. J. 17 " In School Geo. M. 15 " " " Stephen A. 13 " " " Martha P. 10 " " " james B. 10 " " " Minerva F. 6 " (Minerva Frances) Robt. L. 5 " Children in order: (all childer born DeKalb Co. Alabama)(hole puched in d. dates) 1. Sarah Ann b.20 Oct. 1840 d. 20 May 191_ , md. James (Jim) Mason 2. Mary Jane b.01 Feb. 1842 d.17 Jun 1912 md. John Case 3. Margaret Elizabeth b.13 Sep. 1843 d. 4, Jul 190_ md. T.H. Benton Cross 26 Dec. 1872 4. Lucind Catherine b. 7, Feb. 1847 md. Billo Smith 5. Rufina Casada b. 9, Oct. 1850 d. 8, Jun 191__ md. Robert Paris Blevins on 15 Dec. 1868 6. William Jasper b. 25,Aug. 1850 md. Emma Towsend 7. George Martin b. 2, Oct. 1854 d.26, May 191__ md. (1) Mary Agnes Carroll on 27 Jul 1876 md. (2) Louisa Jane Blevins on 5, Feb. 1882 8. Stephen Austin b. 13 Sep. 1856 9. Martha Paralee b. 2, Nov. 1857 d. 20, Mar. 188_ . Never married/no issues 10. James Brock b. 2, Nov. 1857 d. 28 , Jan 191_ md. Nannie Pope 16 Aug. 1888 11. Minerva Frances b. 15 Nov. 1863 md. Thomas (Tom) Bracken 12. Robert Lee b. 12 Apr. 1865 d, 14 May 195_ Md. (1) Malvina Eliz Blevins on 15 Dec. 1885 md. (2) Josie Cantrell on 3 Feb. 1923 Nancy Jane Tarzana , Ca. April P.S. Now I have to try and change my information to George W. Cagle , this should be interesting.