Nadeen, David & List, Having checked my Shaw records, there was no connection to Nadeen's Shaw family. My Shaw family, lived for awhile in Marshall and Calloway Cos; Ky. They later settled in Stewart Co; Tn; and that is where my mother & grandfather, were born. Your Benjamin Jackson Alexander Cagle, is one I am not familiar with. There is a record on the SSI database as follows: BENJAMIN CAGLE 12 Oct 1891 Feb 1975 63957  Piedmont, Wayne, MO   344-14-4365 IL (Before 1951) Write Letter His date of birth matches with your Benjamin Cagle. This shows he died in Feb 1975, and his last known residence. This also shows his card was issued in Illinois before 1951. Nadeen, have you looked at his death certificate? In most cases this will show his wife, mother, and father's names. Either this is your ancestor or two Benjamin Cagle's, sharing the same date of birth. Earl