Carol- Thanks for the reply. Have only been on the Broadwater list since about August, so didn't see what you had in the spring. I really have nothing at all on Charles - do have a little more on his son John. Charles seems to have been a popular Broadwater name, which always adds to the confusion. Lots of info available on the descendants of Col. Charles Broadwater, but can't see where this fits in. Any info you have on this Charles B. will be greatly appreciated. Thanks. Ellen