Susan... it was indeed on Ancestry and I agree, I think this is likely to be your man. He would only have been about 27 (?) at the time. I imagine that his conduct must have been very worthy and, if his service was so remarkable it is perhaps why he was brought in as an older man during WW2? Flailing about with hypotheses :-) Found on: British Army WWI Medal Rolls Index Cards, 1914-1920 by inputting 'Arthur J S Hinton'. Karen Visit the new Ridout family history website and blog at: www.the-ridouts.com