Perhaps Adam's obit in the 1896 Gospel Messenger on p 382 will answer the question or maybe muddy the waters further. Findagrave is listing him with the dates of Feb 10, 1815-May 16, 1896 buried in Moultrie Chapel Cemetery, Homeworth, Columbiana County OH. The transcriber has linked him as the son of Casper Benjamin Stump [1786-1837] & Sarah Elizabeth Fishel [1789-1852] also buried there. Unfortunately there are not photographs of these markers. From: "David Myers" <[email protected]> > Pat, > > I was wondering how certain you are about the birth date for Adam Stump. > He married the Lydia Longanecker in my family and there seems to be some > dispute about his birth date especially. Don & Jeanine Hartman have the > dates as 10 Feb 1815 [sic?] and 6 [sic?] May 1896, while "Alexander Mack > the Tunker and Descendants" -- Rev. Freeman Ankrum (1943) has March 3, > 1818 and May 6 [sic?], 1896. Other sources have dates that are different > than these. > > Thanks, > > David Myers > > On Fri, 29 Apr 2011 08:38:03 -0400 "Pat McArtor" <[email protected]> > writes: >> To Merle Rummel, >> I know that you said that you don't know a lot about the other >> Stumps who settled in the northern Ind area but I might as well ask >> whether you know anything about this family: >> >> Benjamin Stump b 1 Sep 1791 Pa. d 19 Apr 1863 N. Liberty, St Joseph >> Co, In. >> Mar: ______ Anna Mary Spatz (no further info) >> >> 1) Adam Stump b 3 Mar 1818 Pa. d 16 May 1896 Prob Columbiana Co, >> Oh >> Mar: 21 Frb 1841 CCO [Columbiana Co, Oh] to >> Lydia Longenecker b 3 Apr 1818 Oh. d 30 Jul 1890 CCO [Source: >> Adam Stump Bible]