I think L-331 is probably part of L-142. It is a lot of circumstantial evidence. Anyone care to look and see? I have a lot of census plus the info in L-142. Is it enough to merge them? I believe they are brothers David Bole Beatty and John Campbell Beatty. Sons of L-142 John and grandsons of John and Martha Bole Beatty. Donna L-3 This is where I think they fit in L-142. 9. JOHN3 BEATTY (WILLIAM 2, SAMUEL 1) was born May 24, 1790, and died July 09, 1849. He married MARTHA BOLE. Children of JOHN BEATTY and MARTHA BOLE are: i. MARY4 BEATTY, m. SAMUEL CALDWELL. ii. SARAH BEATTY, m. WILLIAM CALDWELL. iii. JOHN BEATTY, m. (1) ANNIE HASLETT; m. (2) ANALINA JOHNSON. iv. DAVID BEATTY, d. Died unmarried. v. ISABELLA BEATTY, m. PETER DUFFY. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Laurel Baty" <laurelbaty@comcast.net> To: <bp2000@rootsweb.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 02, 2011 12:57 PM Subject: Re: [BP2000] John Guthrie Beatty, b. 1826, Ireland Hi Barry, It look like L331: Lineage 331 1 John Gunther Beatty b: 1828 in Butler, PA . 2 John Cambell Beatty b: 09/29/1855 in Butler? PA d: in Everett, WA ... +Mary Carr ... 3 John Fransis Beatty b: 03/20/1889 in E St. Louis MO d: 12/10/1950 in Everett, WA ... +Lyla Grace Horney m: 03/12/1913 in Everett, WA Katherine Elizabeth Beatty Laurel Baty, L252 -----Original Message----- From: bp2000-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:bp2000-bounces@rootsweb.com] On Behalf Of sqrbear@cox.net Sent: Wednesday, March 02, 2011 1:40 PM To: Bp2000-L Subject: [BP2000] John Guthrie Beatty, b. 1826, Ireland Descendant Indented Chart 1. John Guthrie Beatty, b. 1826, Ireland +unknown spouse 2.David Bale Beatty, b. 1857 2.John Campbell Beatty, b. 1855, Butler, PA +Mary Carr, b. 1858, NJ 3. Dr. John Francis Beatty, b. 20 Mar 1889, IL +Lyla Grace Horney, b. 1887, IA 4. Mary Alice Beatty, b. 1914, WA +John Norman Aamodt , b. 1913, WA 4. John Henry Beatty, b. 1916, WA +Elizabeth Kurtz Carroll, b. 1918