I posted information on this family and now have found what I believe are the parents of Edward, Bridget, Annie, and Catherine: 1850 census, Hazle, Luzerne PA Boyle, Charles, age 30, m, Ireland --Rose, 27, f, Ireland --Biddy, 4, f, PA --Edward, 2, m, PA --Ann, 4/12, f, PA Quinn, Michael, 35, m, Ireland Gillespie, Charles, 60, m, Ireland 1860 census, Hazle, Luzerne, PA Boyle, Charles, 35, m, Ireland --Rose, 38, f, Ireland --Bridget, 13, f, PA --Edward, 12, m, PA --Ann, 10, f, PA --James, 8, m, PA --Catherine, 6, f, PA --Susannah, 1, f, PA 1870 census Hazleton borough, Luzerne, PA Boyle, Rose, 49, f, Ireland --Edward, 20, m, PA --James, 17, m, PA --Catherine, 13, f, PA --Susan, 9, f, PA --Charles, 8, m, PA 1880 census Hazleton, Luzerne, PA Boyle, Rose, w, 59, Ireland --James, 27, PA, school teacher --Charles, 18, PA --Susie, 21, PA This doesn't resolve why my grand aunt or great aunt, Mary D. Boyle was living with the Edward Boyle family in 1920, but someone might help connect her grandfather, John Boyle to Charles Boyle. Pam