I found them in the 1860 census. 1860 Federal Census: Ohio Osnaburgh Township, Stark County Enumerated 28 August 1860 Page 216B Lines 13-18, HH 1309/1309 Michael Rovenstein 35/Male/White/Laborer/-----$75/PA Ann Rovenstein 30/Female/White/PA Dallas Rovenstein 10/Male/White/AttendedSchool/OH Uriah Rovenstein 9/Male/White/AttendedSchool/OH Henry Rovenstein 6/Male/White/OH Margaret A. Rovenstein 3/Female/White/OH ----------------------- Researched and Submitted by Gloria Bushong