Jess...responding to your request for help on the Charles Boggs/Ann Scobee line. don't get your hopes up, I know nothing! However, In the last couple of days I have seen 2 references to a William between John Livingston Boggs (you said James Livingston) and James, the immigrant. Al Rhods responded that it was not proven that William was James' father. Do you have Proof!!??? I never heard of him before 2 days ago. Of course, there's no proof of John Livingston either, but would like to fit William in if he belongs...thanks! Kathy Hughes [email protected]