Beth, I have a lady who contact me from Katy ,Texas that says she is helping her children do their family tree and although she is divorced from their father of many years. She said her father in law was William Robert Brooks Seale , who was Billy's sixth child by Emma. She said she knew Hattie and she had a daughter named Earlene. I only have George,Mattie Pearl,Hattie,Lillie,and Ina Lee for Billy's second family. Do you know if there was a sixth? I am not doubting her but the only William Robert's I have are Barrett's. I gave her Margie's phone #, because I am sure she would know,right? Let me know if you can fill any of the blanks for us. I do have a Robert C. but I have him listed with Billy's first set of children. I only have he was married to Lillie and never found any more on him. This man supposed fought in the war with his father Billy. She does know that his father was a black smith in Madisonville. So it has to be our William Joseph Seale. Hope you are doing okay , Love Deb