Hello listers, Unbeknownst to you, I've been trying to include the AYR-List to post this look-up, and it's been a delivery failure three times. I have now redone the e-address, again, but without the 'L'. Regards Judy in BC Can -----Original Message----- From: Judy Minchinton [mailto:grannym2@dccnet.com] Sent: February-09-10 10:27 AM To: 'William MCDILL'; 'Eleanor Haggarty'; 'jecroft@att.net'; AYRSHIRE-L@rootsweb.com Subject: RE: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. Hello all, What follows truly belongs in the 'long-shot' file of probabilities; but it could be that Margaret CARNOCHAN, father David, is a sister to 'my' Mathew CARNOCHAN who is father of the Marion in the subject line of recent previous postings. #3 Margaret fits with the Margaret sent by Bill, and #7 'my' Mathew - who names his second son David - his first son Charles after his wife's father. I digress..... >From the Br.Vital Records Index v2: 1. CARNOCHAN, John Gender: Male Christening Date: 5 Mar 1749 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland, Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 2. CARNOCHAN, David Gender: Male Christening Date: 25 Aug 1751 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 3. CARNOCHAN, Margaret Gender: Female Christening Date: 4 Aug 1754 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 4. CARNOCHAN, James Gender: Male Christening Date: 28 Aug 1757 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 5. CARNOCHAN, Dorothy Gender: Female Christening Date: 7 Sep 1761 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 6. CARNOCHAN, Robert Gender:Male Christening Date: 25 Jun 1764 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 7. CARNOCHAN, Matthew Gender:Male Christening Date: 16 Jan 1768 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 8. CARNOCHAN, Hugh Gender: Male Christening Date: 2 Sep 1772 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 9. CARNOCHAN, Helen Gender: Female Christening Date: 6 Jan 1776 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 10. CARNOCHAN, Janet Gender: Female Christening Date: 13 Dec 1777 Recorded in: Kirkoswald, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Source: FHL Film 1041391 Dates: 1694 - 1855 More ingredients for the soup: there was another CARNOCHAN birth, father David but in neighbouring Maybole County - and there is a mother named. CARNOCHAN, Mary Gender: Female Christening Date: 2 Sep 1744 Recorded in: Maybole, Ayrshire, Scotland Father: David CARNOCHAN Mother: Agness HENDERSON Source: FHL Film 1041396 Dates: 1711 - 1820 If Agness is the mother of all these children then she bore children over a 33 year time span. Mercy! If the first listed Carnochan births are all the same father, and perhaps the same mother that's still a 28 year span. It's very easy to make wrong assumptions. If sks could look up these births on the FHL film to see if mother is there - or any precious margin notes adding useful information...quick search hasn't found MI's..... Out to the yard now, not having winter temps this year and fruit trees must be pruned now. Regards, Judy in BC Can -----Original Message----- From: William MCDILL [mailto:wmcdill0201@rogers.com] Sent: February-08-10 3:49 PM To: Eleanor Haggarty; Judy Minchinton; jecroft@att.net Subject: RE: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. Found the following birth record: 04/08/1754 CARNOCHAN MARGARET DAVID CARNOCHAN/ F KIRKOSWALD /AYR Bill McDill -----Original Message----- From: ayrshire-bounces@rootsweb.com [mailto:ayrshire-bounces@rootsweb.com]On Behalf Of Eleanor Haggarty Sent: February 8, 2010 18:38 To: Judy Minchinton; jecroft@att.net; ayrshire@rootsweb.com Subject: Re: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. Hi - thanks for your reply. The one I am interested in trying to find out more about is a Margaret Carnochan married in 1773 in Irvine to a William Fletcher. Have not been able to find parents, nor anything else about her. Eleanor ----- Original Message ----- From: "Judy Minchinton" <grannym2@dccnet.com> To: "'Eleanor Haggarty'" <b.wood@sympatico.ca>; <jecroft@att.net>; <ayrshire@rootsweb.com> Sent: Monday, February 08, 2010 4:21 PM Subject: RE: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. > Hi Eleanor, > > One of my sets of x4 gt.gparents is Charles EDGAR, and Annable NICOL > who marry 10 Feb 1761 in Dailly. Several variant spellings for Annable > including Anaple. > > Charles and Annable have 7 children and their daughter Annaple EDGAR > marries Matthew CARNOCHAN abt 1792 and they have 6 children: Charles > 29 May 1793, Janet 14 Oct 1794, Annaple 7 Jun 1796, Marion 30 Nov > 1797, Margaret 9 Nov 1799, and David 10 Aug 1801. > > I have information on three of the children of Matthew CARNOCHAN and > Annaple > EDGAR: > > Janet CARNOCHAN m. Robert NIMMO 14 Apr 1822, and they have 7 children. > > Marion CARNOCHAN m. William CROSBIE 12 Feb 1820, and they have 8 children. > > Margaret CARNOCHAN m. Thomas MEREDITH abt 1825, and they have 7 children. > > Born 1768 in Kirkoswald, Mathew CARNOCHAN'S father is David CARNOCHAN. > > Perhaps this will help in determining if there is, or is not, a > connection for you. I could post more information on the children of > the three families listed here if that would help. > > Regards, Judy in BC Can > > -----Original Message----- > From: Eleanor Haggarty [mailto:b.wood@sympatico.ca] > Sent: February-08-10 12:12 PM > To: Judy Minchinton; jecroft@att.net; ayrshire@rootsweb.com > Subject: Re: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. > > I also think I have a Carnochan in my family, but haven't been able to > prove yet. > There is also a Charles born 29/05/1793 - Anaple - 07/06/1796 - David > in > 10/08/1801 - Jannet 14/10/1794 - Margaret in 09/11/1799 Eleanor > ----- Origina l mes age ----- > From: "Judy Minchinton" <grannym2@dccnet.com> > To: <jecroft@att.net>; <ayrshire@rootsweb.com> > Sent: Monday, February 08, 2010 11:08 AM > Subject: Re: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. > > >> Jo-Ann, >> >> Thank you so very much - I was hoping someone would be able to do that. >> I'll return to thinking she's mine now. I'm thrilled. >> >> I guess she just got missed when transcriptions got done. >> >> Many thanks to the others who responded, it all helps. >> >> Regards, >> >> Judy in BC Can >> >> >> >> -----Original Message----- >> From: ayrshire-bounces@rootsweb.com >> [mailto:ayrshire-bounces@rootsweb.com] >> On Behalf Of jecroft@att.net >> Sent: February-08-10 2:12 AM >> To: ayrshire@rootsweb.com >> Subject: Re: [AYR] Marion Carnochan c.1798-5 May1870. >> >> Judy, >> >> This looks like your Marion in the Maybole OPR. >> >> Marion CARNAHAN b. 30 NOV 1797 >> Parents: Matthew CARNAHAN and Annaple EDGAR >> >> -- >> Jo-Ann Croft >> >> >> ------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to >> AYRSHIRE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the >> quotes in the subject and the body of the message >> >> >> ------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to >> AYRSHIRE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the >> quotes in the subject and the body of the message >> > > ------------------------------- To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to AYRSHIRE-request@rootsweb.com with the word 'unsubscribe' without the quotes in the subject and the body of the message