Hello Rhonda and fellow Jurors This is the first time I have been able to respond to the original readings (i.e.the case) and I have resisted reading the other jurors comments until now so I can't be influenced. This I will do as soon as I post my preliminary verdict or should I say comments. I am inclined to think that Elizabeth was a bit of a boozer also. While the hit on the head could have caused her loss of memory, (that is if she was telling the truth about her memory) she may also have been in a drunken stupor. I wonder if the description of the wound by one of the witnesses being a small hole with lots of blood on the floor and on the riffle also. I think they have got into a fight, both throwing hits at each other, he has picked up the gun and hit her around the head. I will now read the other jurors verdicts and make further comments (as we should). This is quite fun. I'm in Sydney where is everyone else. Cheryl