Have had a look at the index to "Historical Records of the CC of NSW" for Robley. There are several refs for John Robley, Sr and Jr, but all seem to refer to a court case or hearing in Jan 1861, probably they were giving evidence (just my guess). Perhaps some kind Lister has time to check it out for you on the microfilmed records of the Bench Books and Court Cases at Gosford Library? Regards, Gwen