Ruth, I believe you are correct on #5-8 on the Gilbert Atwood list. #7-Thomas is my gggrandfather's brother and his son is Patrick. They are listed in the 1850 Morgan Co., Ohio census records. There is a book called "The Genealogy of the Gilbert Atwood family" and I have found a copy in Ky. of this book. In fact I was just in touch with the library today and they are willing to loan it and I should have it by early next week. It was written by an Atwood descendent born in 1910 so it probably is pretty accurate. I should be able to share info next week. Barb