Hi David, Am posting your answer to the list, for others to see, as I know some of them are from Henry Ashby >Bounds Ashby>, etc. But, if you paged down to the first message. You see where Debbie had found this marriage of an H. Ashby to a Lewis Houghton in 1836. How does this fit into your Hulda that married your ancestor John Threkill in 1835 in Hopkins Co., KY. Maybe I'm not reading the info correctly, if so let me know? Anyway, however and whenever, I'm glad to get all the information for the list subscribers. Thanks for writing and sharing. Sue