Those names and dates are identical, but the places are definitely not! I have no proof, and no documentation, other than a family "pedigree" composed by one of their descendants many years ago (and given me by a newly discovered cousin).. The story in the "pedigree" rings true in that, as far as it goes, it meshes with the information that my immediate family has had handed down to them. You can check my GEDCOM on Rootsweb under Armstrong-Robertson. My user name is jarcjac.