This is a Message Board Post that is gatewayed to this mailing list. Surnames: Thornton Classification: Query Message Board URL: http://boards.ancestry.com/mbexec/msg/rw/3R.2ADE/662.1 Message Board Post: Robert, We have already proven Patsey Jane was not Arthur and Anatasia's daughter. Have checked the census records and there is no reference to her on them plus David Gonzalez has no records in his family file. She has shown up in the book written by Rocheslle Farris on the Thorntons and Gachets but this also proved to be inaccurate when I got the documents that were supposedly used as source.. Have been unable to get any of her relatives to cooperate in finding out the correct documents they found her name on. Patsey Jane's husband John A McDuffie was in Florida 1861 and joined the Morton Confederates during the Civil War. If you have access to the book "Florida Soldiers in the Civil War" which Lists Morton Confederates you might check it out and see if there is a clue in there about John and Patsey Jane. Maybe she is some kin to Arthur I don't know with out some sort of evidence..